Pavlov, metropolitan state university of denver, philosophy department, faculty member. He is known largely for his original conception of the ideal, which he deployed against both idealist and crude materialist forms of reductionism, including official soviet diamat. From that standpoint logic also cannot be anything else than a theory explaining the universal schemas of the development of knowledge and of the material world by. Lev vygotsky and evald ilyenkov arto artinian the problematic of soviet marxism soviet marxism is often understood as a tradition that with the exception of.
Evald ilyenkov held that logic was not a formal science but a reflection of scientific praxis and that the rules of logic are not independent of the content. Quantum physics occupies a fascinating place at the cutting edge of modern scientific research. The philosophy of dialectical materialism, materialist dialectics, the logic of the. Evald ilyenkov and creative soviet marxism historical materialism at. The ideal in human activity evald vasilyevich ilyenkov. Ilyenkov dialectical logic recognition of the uselessness of the official, formal, scholastic version of logic as the organon of real thought and of the development of scientific knowledge was the leitmotif of all the advanced, progressive philosophers of the time. This book traces the development of dialectical logic within the history of modern western philosophy, culminating in marx s materialist dialectics. This essay by evald vasilyevich ilyenkov 192479, on the coincidence of logic with dialectics and the theory of knowledge of materialism.
Ilyenkov, following marx, looks for clues to the nature of the ideal in the structure of social relations. When ilyenkov wrote his first major work the dialectic of the abstract and the concrete in marxs capital in 1956, the director of the institute of philosophy, fedoseyev, having read the proofs, ordered the typesetting of the book to be destroyed. Notes for the spinoza lecture k dokladu o spinoze the history of dialectics now in draft. Pavlov was born and raised in the soviet union currently russian federation, he therefore. This article traces the publication history of evald ilyenkovs early text, cosmology of the spirit, it presents its. Dialectical logic 2 ently of them, in other words, creates a mental reproduction of it, reconstructs its selfdevelopment, recreates it in the logic of the movement of concepts so as to recreate it later in fact in experiment or in practice.
Essays on its history and theory by evald vasilyevich ilyenkov book resume. Dialectics they believe cannot act the same everywhere, in his particular and universal at the same time as it can be presented only as a dialectic thinking and as a dialectics of the development of human knowledge, that is, as the logic and theory of knowledge. Please read our short guide how to send a book to kindle. Abstract evald vasilyevich ilyenkov was a soviet philosopher who had as the core of his work the confrontation of neopositivism.
The logic now in use serves rather to fix and give stability to. The thermonuclear conflagration of the final revolution could not possibly be looked upon favourably by the soviet censor. Evald ilyenkov and creative soviet marxism levant and oittinen provide a window into the subterranean tradition of creative soviet marxism, which developed on the margins of the soviet academe and remains largely outside the orbit of contemporary theory in the west. Dialectical logic and contradictions of the modern culture 6. A new book, quantum social science, by andrei khrennikov and emmanuel haven argues that applying the logic of quantum theory to social systems can take. And although theoretical research into capitalist development and the devices of political resistance was transformed and pushed forward, it failed to recompose and unfold a. Read quasiappropriation of dialectical materialism. The passionate logic of evald ilyenkov real democracy. Logic then is the theoretical representation of such thinking. Evald ilenkov as an interpreter of spinoza request pdf. Dialectical logic paperback april 16, 2014 by evald ilyenkov author 5. Essays in hegelian dialectic download ebook pdf, epub. Ilyenkovs role in the development of culturalhistorical psychology 5.
Ilyenkovs essay thought as an attribute of substance from dialectical logic. A preface to a new theory of methodology and ontology. Contradiction as a category of dialectical logic 11. Subjectiveobjective dichotomy encyclopedia article.
Dialectical logic by evald vasilyevich ilyenkov pdf free. Evald ilyenkov one source refers to a witch hunt against him. Contingency and necessity in evald ilyenkovs communist. Evald vassilievich ilyenkov was a marxist author and soviet philosopher. Principal dates of ilyenkovs life and work 19241979 if you would like to contribute to this work please email us. The contradiction as a category of dialectical logic. An attempt to establish in general the objective role of thinking matter in the system of universal interaction a philosophicalpoetical phantasmagoria based on the principles of dialectical materialism i. Evald ilenkov as an interpreter of spinoza article in studies in east european thought 573. The ideal in human activity evald vasilyevich ilyenkov download bok.
Dialectical logic quotes by evald vasilyevich ilyenkov. The latter two works were published posthumously as ilyenkov committed suicide in 1979. Below is the copy of the abstract of ilyenkovs work from the link above. Evald ilyenkov with his living interest in hegel and the young marx who was. Braun, on trends in the status of dialectical logic.
Essays on hegel s logic download ebook pdf, epub, tuebl, mobi. Evald ilyenkov and walter benjamin on the significance of material. His dialectics of the ideal openly aligns itself with marxs capital, especially with the analysis of the valueform in the process of commodity exchange given in the f. Vassili pavlovich ilienkov conjuge olga salimova premios ordem da guerra patriotica grau 2, n. Some thoughts on the use of dialectics 7 hand, a struggle on the issues of difference, resistance and subjectivation. Principal dates of ilyenkov s life and work 19241979 if you would like to contribute to this work please email us. Pdf dialectical logic by evald vasilyevich ilyenkov download. The thermonuclear conflagration of the final revolution could not. On the philosophical hypotheses of evald vasilevich ilyenkov. Dialectic tends to imply a process of evolution and so does not naturally fit within formal logic see logic and dialectic. Numerical analysis, 2010, 888 pages, richard burden, j. Lupus books is currently working on translating some of ilyenkovs works. This process is particularly marked in hegelian dialectic and even more so in marxist dialectic which may rely on the evolution of ideas over longer time periods in the real world.
Studies logic, evald ilyenkov, and soviet philosophy. In contrast to this dialecticalmaterialist understanding of the ideal, ilyenkov. Ilyenkov, the ideal in human activity marxist internet archive publications, pacifica ca, 2009 claude m. Lupus books is currently working on translating some of ilyenkov s works. Evald ilyenkov did original work on the materialist development of hegel s dialectics, notable for his account of concrete universals. He also researched the questions of psychology, pedagogy and history of philosophy. This book traces the historical development of dialectical thought through premarxist philosophers, and then deals with issues of interest in marxist dialectics including ilyenkov s specialty the question of the generalideal in dialectics. His works include dialectical logic 1977, leninist dialectics and the metaphysics of positivism 1982 and the dialectics of the abstract and concrete in marxs capital 1982. Oct 21, 20 it was ilyenkovs own logic which allowed the dissident mathematician shafarevich to unmask communism as a secret cult of nothingness and as denial of lifes foundations.
First developed in the early 20th century, quantum theory is allowing todays scientists to plumb new depths when it comes to matter and motion. As the johnson government organises a very british coup, challenging the power of the state is ever more urgent. It was ilyenkovs own logic which allowed the dissident mathematician shafarevich to unmask communism as a secret cult of nothingness and as denial of lifes foundations. From that standpoint logic also cannot be anything else than a theory explaining the universal schemas of the development of knowledge and of the material world by social man.
Dialectical logic, essays on its history and theory. Evald ilyenkov and walter benjamin on the significance of. He followed hegel in insisting that formal logic had been sublated, arguing that logic needed to be a unity of form and content and to state actual truths about the objective world. Dialectical logic, essays on its history and theory publisher. Ilyenkov is widely considered to be the most important soviet philosopher in the poststalin period. Ilyenkov and humanistic tradition in the world of philosophy 2. Scribd is the worlds largest social reading and publishing site. May 31, 2014 below is the copy of the abstract of ilyenkovs work from the link above. Dialectical logic by evald ilyenkov, econarch institute, electronic classics series, the editor, indonesia is a portable document file produced as part of an ongoing student publication project to bring classical works of literature, in english, to free and easy access of those wishing to make use of them. Essays on its history and theory, evald vasilyevich ilyenkov, jan 1, 2008, dialectic, 372 pages. This book traces the historical development of dialectical thought through premarxist philosophers, and then deals with issues of interest in marxist dialectics including ilyenkovs specialty the question of the generalideal in dialectics. Evald ilyenkov did original work on the materialist development of hegels dialectics, notable for his account of concrete universals.
A commentary on evald ilyenkovs cosmology of the spirit stasis. Ilyenkov wrote some of the best philosophy to ever come out of the ussr during the destalinization period. The dialectical logic of evald ilyenkov and western european marxism. And although theoretical research into capitalist development and the devices of political resistance was transformed and pushed forward, it failed to recompose and unfold a communist perspective. At a symposium organised by the international friends of ilyenkov ifi, cofounders corinna lotz and penny cole showed the contemporary relevance of oppositional soviet philosopher evald ilyenkov s dialectical notion of the ideal.
205 522 24 437 1267 192 431 1131 151 709 1236 1359 152 1423 443 970 457 192 1119 1284 323 1461 38 1246 1118 318 823 800 1089 224 618 339 248 1375 283 1111 1018